Tuesday, 18 September 2007

BIG SAM BLAST FOR `LUCKY` RAFA

Newcastle manager Sam Allardyce has criticised Rafael Benitez's tenure at Anfield, suggesting the Spaniard would have been "very lucky to be in a job" if he had not reached two Champions League finals.

Allardyce insists Benitez places too much emphasis on European competition instead of launching a sustained bid for the Barclays Premier League title - but believes his success on the Continent could have saved his job.

Liverpool have finished fifth, third and third domestically under Benitez as well as winning the European Cup in 2005 and reaching the final last season.

Allardyce, speaking to Zoo magazine, said: "Rafa would be very lucky to be in a job if he hadn't got to two Champions League finals, because they have had some very, very poor finishes in the Premier League.

"While they are a very good Champions League team, they are not a Premier League-winning team yet.

"They don't have that mentality to win that yet.

"Being a foreigner, Rafa doesn't understand it's supposed to be Premier League first and Champions League second."

www.football365.com

All Blacks accused of Pacific pillage - again

By GUY MacGIBBON - Stuff.co.nz | Tuesday, 18 September 2007

The accusations by the British press against New Zealand rugby for allegedly poaching the Pacific's finest are so predictable that this World Cup the defence came first.

The first strains of a chorus from the north bemoaning New Zealand's supposed pillaging of South Seas rugby talent was sounded yesterday by the All Blacks' most vocal critic - the Welshman and English rugby apologist Stephen Jones.

Jones writes that Samoa would be a world rugby powerhouse, perhaps even world champions, if their finest talent had not been stolen by New Zealand.

He supports his assertion by offering the statistic that five af the All Blacks' World Cup squad are Samoan-born.

But his major evidence had already been shot down by Dominion Post rugby writer Jim Kayes, who pointed out that 12 of the Samoan squad were Kiwi-born in a column a week ago.

England's impending showdown with Samoa provided the soapbox for Jones, a long-time baiter of New Zealand rugby, to attack the All Blacks.

"Just how great would Samoa be if they had been allowed to choose all their eligible players. In my opinion, they could well by now become world champions," Jones wrote in his Sunday Times column.

"It is hardly a shock that Samoans as a race, and especially Samoan rugby players, flock to New Zealand. It is life, and a living.

"It is also the most fabulous good fortune for Kiwis that they are the nearest country of any commercial strength to the most remarkable rugby nursery in the world, bar none. Bryan Williams, Olo Brown, Michael Jones, Va'aiga Tuigamala and Tana Umaga are all in the pantheon of All Black greats, yet all could have played their whole careers for Samoa."

Anticipating this well worn set-piece, Kayes mounted the defence for New Zealand rugby a week in advance.

In a column appearing on Stuff on September 12 headlined Time British scribes got it right, Kayes pointed out that there are more New Zealand-born players in Samoa's squad than Samoan-born players in the All Blacks - debunking the myth that New Zealand gobbles up the Pacific's finest while offering nothing in return.

Kayes also writes that at least eight more of the Samoan squad have played first class rugby in New Zealand, their coach, All Blacks great Michael Jones, was also born in New Zealand, and assistant coach Pita Fatialofa was a Ponsonby and Auckland stalwart.

"The attacks on the racial make up of the All Blacks have always conveniently ignored the immigration trends of Pacific Islanders moving to New Zealand and the diverse cultural mix in our major cities," writes Kayes.

So, the evidence has been presented on both sides. The debate will undoubtedly continue in perpetuity on talkback, on rugby blogs, in bars, by water coolers and in the pages of newspapers - without resolution.

And Jones's verdict on the upcoming clash between England and Samoa? An England win.

"... but I believe it will be close, and that Samoa may come close to disproving the theory that modern-day excellence in test rugby depends on funding, technology, time together, endless fretting over tiny detail, and pay cheque. Sometimes, it depends on will and your love affair with your own people, and their struggle. England beware."

Portugal puffery glosses over the real points

By LINDSAY KNIGHT - RugbyHeaven | Tuesday, 18 September 2007

As rugby's World Cup enters its second week of what might be termed its "phoney war", a sober, dispassionate observer must wonder whether some, especially in the television media, have suspended any public obligation to be responsible critics.

To suggest, as some commentators in television and others in the media have done, that Portugal's performance against the All Blacks justifies the places of "minnow" nations in the tournament and that it rebutted any argument for streamlining the format, defies all that is logical and rational.

Sure, the Portuguese brought plenty of spirit and endeavour to the game, they sung their national anthem with passion and they celebrated with gusto their scoring achievements. But the reality remained that this was a hopeless mismatch which did as much to advance rugby as a global sport as the All Blacks' 1995 145-17 win over Japan.

Portugal was still slaughtered by a century of points by an All Black team which, by its lofty standards, did not play all that well and which, with so many players either out of practice or out of position, was somewhat disjointed.

It was yet another gross distortion of what a test match is supposed to be about and in a sense an effrontery to those who have gone before when an international cap and jersey were something precious.

Think of those outstanding players of the past who, through circumstances, ill luck and the tighter criteria which applied in their time, never had as much as a second on the field as an All Black – the likes of the fine Auckland captain of the 1960s Bob Graham or the Waikato loose forward of the 1980s and early-90s, Duane Monkley.

And what might that stalwart of Auckland and North Auckland sides of the 1960s and '70s, Frank Colthurst, have thought when in the frolic against Portugal no fewer than three hookers – Andrew Hore, Anton Oliver and Keven Mealamu – all took the field.

It is incongruous, too, to reflect on the worth of an All Black jersey now if an old team photo of the 1950s is studied. Then, players who were in the squad as reserves were included in the photo but without the silver fern on their jerseys. Now any Tom, Dick and Harry can go to the nearest sports store and run around in jerseys which we are told are replicas but which look very much like the real thing.

You can only wonder again how invaluable a soft exercise against a side like Portugal will be when suddenly the All Blacks find themselves in a quarter-final which is looking increasingly like being France. It's a scary thought, but in the now infamous semifinal in 1999 France went into that game also having struggled in all previous matches and, indeed, being lucky to escape with a win over Fiji.

Some essential questions arise: what value has there been in taking Keith Robinson and Reuben Thorne to the tournament when clearly even before the team left New Zealand they were far from 100%? What must Alex Wyllie and John Hart be thinking? About the only thing they agreed on in 1991 was that they needed Mike Brewer in their squad, only to have him ruled out through a late fitness test.

And, given the ease with which the All Blacks have cruised through their pool games, has the disruption the rest of the New Zealand season has suffered for the sake of winning the World Cup been worth it?

At this stage, even though there is still a long way to go in the tournament, it seems a safe bet that it will be an all-southern hemisphere final and, dare it be suggested, in view of the way Argentina has performed, it may even be all-southern semis, with the Pumas meeting the impressive Springboks.

Which leaves a few more questions lingering for apologists for northern hemisphere rugby, mainly those who have had their bank accounts inflated by wealthy club owners, and myopic southern hemisphere knockers such as exist in the UK press.

One would have thought the message would have penetrated after the misfortunes in New Zealand of Clive Woodward's Lions in 2005. That side failed miserably because the players could not adjust to the greater pace and tempo with which the game is played in this country.

The power of the pound, the Euro, and even the yen may be damaging to rugby in South Africa, Australia and especially New Zealand. But for every Luke McAlister who is lost there is a Stephen Brett or Stephen Donald coming on to take their place. Instead of gloating about raiding southern hemisphere stocks, British journalists should be more concerned that their own national interests are being seriously compromised, much like has already happened with their soccer and cricket.

Who was that masked man?

By GREG FORD in Aix-en-Provence - Fairfax Media | Tuesday, 18 September 2007

image

It was a moment of levity amid the often hum-drum life for a touring All Black. And it came from the most unexpected of quarters.
All Blacks take time out.

About 50 media were interviewing half a dozen members of the team in their hotel garden when out of nowhere came a rather large individual running manically through the throng.

He had a hood over his head and it later transpired it was Carl Hayman doing his best impression of a gimp. The big All Black prop is garnering himself a reputation as a prankster after years of dead-panning it in public.

He appeared to get a kick out of the joke. But, more importantly, so did his team-mates.

The All Blacks are in such a relaxed mood of late it has been the major talking point of the tournament, especially for those who operated in the bad old days when John Mitchell created a siege mentality in the team.

Certainly the weather and the venues the All Blacks have been basing themselves in the south of France have helped. As Jerry Collins explained last week, it's not hard to get out of the bed in the mornings in such magic conditions.

Before they head away to Edinburgh on Friday the team is basing itself in Aix-Provence. Many of the squad simply played golf and cycled around the picturesque city on a rare day off from the grind of training.

Keven Mealamu said it was an ideal place to unwind after a test match which was helping the mood no end.

But there's a little more to it than good coffee and croissants.

It's been slowly building, and the team has a certain air of self-confidence to them at the moment. It's not being borne out in players' comments at the often sterile interview sessions conducted while on tour. But it's discernible in their body language, the way they carry themselves and interact with each other. They're enjoying themselves. That might sound an odd thing to say, but all too often All Black teams have been unhappy camps.

The locals are doing their bit too.

The French, with the odd exception, seem pleased to have the All Blacks in their midst, especially on game day. Their famous indifference to anything but themselves is providing the team with welcome respite.

Mealamu, an honest guy, admitted the team is now better at handling the pressure of being All Blacks. They have learned to enjoy their position of privilege and can now flick the switch and move into game mode when the time comes. It means the team doesn't waste valuable mental energy on things they can't control.

And the language barrier in France is also proving a bonus rather than a hindrance,

"A lot of us don't speak the language so we don't understand what is being written about us in the papers," he said.

"It puts us out of the public eye so the boys are just having a good time."

I believe that's partly due to the fact they don't feel as if they have anything to prove to anyone else. Their record in recent years speaks for itself. They know they are a class team and are comfortable with that. Of course they want to prove they are capable of becoming world champions. But I get the impression they have everything in perspective at the moment.

Carl Hayman included.

Wales ring the changes

Tuesday 18th September 2007

Fly-half Stephen Jones will take over as captain of a Wales side featuring 10 personnel changes for the Pool B clash with Japan at the Millennium Stadium on Thursday.

Jones is at the helm for the eighth time in his career in the absence of the injured Gareth Thomas, who is ruled out for the next two weeks with a rib cartilage injury, and the Scarlets fly-half is just one kick away from converting his 100th international try.

In the backs, Kevin Morgan returns at full-back, Dafydd James comes onto the wing, Jamie Robinson will partner James Hook in the centre and Mike Phillips gets a run at scrum-half.

Up front, Alix Popham regains the number eight jersey with Jonathan Thomas switching to blindside flanker and Colin Charvis gets the nod ahead of Martyn Williams on the openside.

Will James comes into the second row alongside Alun-Wyn Jones, who retains his place, while hooker Rhys Thomas will be propped by Chris Horsman and Duncan Jones.

The five players to remain in the side from Saturday's defeat to the Wallabies are Stephen Jones, Charvis, Jonathan Thomas, Alun-Wyn Jones and Shane Williams, who will win his 50th cap against Japan.

Williams boasts a Welsh record of 14 tries - four in one match - against the Japanese and will lead the team out ahead of captain Stephen Jones in celebration of becoming the 19th member of the nation's exclusive 50-Cap Club.

Wales lock Ian Evans - named on the bench - has not played any rugby in 10 months after suffering injuries to his shoulder and then his collarbone, but believes he is as prepared as ever to make his return to the field.

"Physically and mentally I am probably in the best shape I can be in. I'm in the squad and it has been a long road to travel but I am finally going to get there in the end," said Evans.

The Ospreys lock, who has been training hard with the rest of the Welsh World Cup squad, is relishing the opportunity to wear the Welsh number five jersey once again.

"Alun-Wyn has been playing out of his boots at the moment but my target is clearly to reclaim the number five jersey. He knows I am not going to give it up without a fight," added Evans.

If Wales can win their remaining pool games they are likely to face South Africa in the quarter-finals.

Wales: 15 Kevin Morgan, 14 Dafydd James, 13 Jamie Robinson, 12 James Hook, 11 Shane Williams, 10 Stephen Jones (c), 9 Michael Phillips, 8 Alix Popham, 7 Colin Charvis, 6 Jonathan Thomas, 5 Alun-Wyn Jones, 4 Will James, 3 Chris Horsman, 2 Thomas Rhys Thomas, 1 Duncan Jones
Replacements: 16 Huw Bennett, 17 Gethin Jenkins, 18 Ian Evans, 19 Martyn Williams, 20 Gareth Cooper, 21 Ceri Sweeney, 22 Tom Shanklin

Date: Thursday, September 20
Venue: Millennium Stadium, Cardiff
Kick-off: 20:00 (19:00 GMT)
Referee: Joël Jutge
Touch judges: Mark Lawrence, Craig Joubert
Television match official: Christophe Berdos
Assessor: Bob Francis

www.planetrugby.com

All Silver for ABs

Tuesday 18th September 2007

When New Zealand take on Scotland on Saturday they will do so not as the All Blacks but the All Silvers, as Scotland will wear their traditional dark blue jerseys.

Scotland won 'home team' advantage before the tournament and therefore have choice of which shirts they will wear. They have, understandably, opted for their usual home kit, forcing New Zealand to don their change jerseys.

Despite the prospect of taking to the field without the famous all black kit the players are not fazed.

"We're still playing for New Zealand and running out with the same guys. I guess it won't make a difference, but we'll see," said second row Chris Jack to IRB.

And he was not the only one with this view, prop Tony Woodcock agreed.

"It's still got the silver fern on, that's the main part," he said.

The lack of an all black kit will not be as big of a worry as the return to fitness and form of Scotland captain Jason White, according to Rodney So'oialo.

"I think he will definitely add something to the Scotland team, but the boys are ready to combat whoever they have," he said.

"We work as a team, that is why New Zealand is successful. We work as a team and that is how you beat individuals."

www.planetrugby.com

Gerrard rallies Reds

Captain wants Liverpool to prove they can challenge on all fronts

Liverpool captain Steven Gerrard has called on the side to prove they are capable of challenging for honours on all fronts this season.

The Reds, who begin their UEFA Champions League campaign away to Porto on Tuesday, have made an encouraging start to the new season by going unbeaten so far.

Liverpool were one of the biggest spenders in pre-season and Gerrard believes everything at the club is geared for success.

England international Gerrard singled out Reds boss Rafa Benitez for special praise describing the Spaniard as the best manager around.

Success

Speaking exclusively in October's Sky Sports magazine, Gerrard says: "At Anfield we've got the new owners who will carry on the good work of David Moores, a new stadium in the pipeline and one of - if not the - best manager in the game.

"We've got the ingredients for real success, but we've got to prove it on the pitch rather than just talking a good game."

Gerrard has been impressed by Liverpool's summer spending and he believes they can only benefit from having competition for places in the side.

"This is the first time in my career that I see genuine competition for every place in the team," continued Gerrard.

Automatic

"There are at least two, even three, players battling for every jersey and that can only be good for everyone.

"The new boys are still getting to grips with the intricacies of English football and the systems and patterns the manager prefers here, but no-one in the dressing room can presume they're an automatic choice because there's so much quality right throughout the squad."

The Reds' midfield dynamo admits the Premier League is Liverpool's top target this season as they look to become domestic champions for the first time in 18 years.

Gerrard is confident Liverpool are not far away from finally bringing England's top prize back to Anfield.

"The league is always your bread and butter as a Liverpool player and we're not far away," added Gerrard.

"With the investment we made in the summer and the squad here staying together, we can promise to push Chelsea and Manchester United all the way this season.

"It's not going to be easy because we want to be competitive on all fronts, but nothing in life worth having is ever easy.

"It's knowing you've worked as hard as hell that makes success so enjoyable.

www.skysports.com