Wednesday, 12 September 2007

I don't feel sorry for McCaw - George Smith

By RUPERT GUINNESS in Montpellier - SMH | Wednesday, 12 September 2007

Wallabies flanker George Smith relishes the prospect of his All Black rival Richie McCaw being targeted as an illegal player by the World Cup referees.

Both openside specialists share an incredible ability for ball scavenging at the breakdown and testing the patience of referees by playing to the limit of laws.

But McCaw, the All Blacks captain, has found himself in front of the blowtorch of vigorous referees throughout this season at Super 14 and test levels.

And Smith, while one of the very best No7s after McCaw, is hardly sympathetic for the Kiwi – fairly or not – having developed a reputation for playing illegally.

"Perception is a lovely word. If the referee gets a perception of what a player is like then that is going to stay with him until it is proven otherwise,'' Smith said. "I am happy for him to get a lot more attention than myself. Then it takes away from his game and my game goes unnoticed. That's a good thing.''

Smith, whose his 80th test in last Saturday's World Cup opener against Japan in Lyon was highlighted by his brilliant 62nd-minute try, admits that mastering the art of a specialist No 7 involves mastering a battle of wits with the referee.

Smith says he doesn't keep hard copy files on referees (or players) to review in preparation for a match, as some players do on their opposition numbers.

But since his 2000 test debut against France, he has accrued a vast mental data base of knowledge about how they handle games and interpret the laws.

"I've played [under] a number of them to know how they play. I play what's in front of me,'' said Smith who will take mental notes about the World Cup referees while they handle other games in case they control a Wallaby match.

Smith took notice of English whistle-blower Tony Spreadbury's run of the World Cup opener between France and Argentina last Friday that saw the hosts lose.

"We saw on that first game that Spreadbury was very quick on the not releasing rule which benefits a lot of backrowers. It will always be consistent with different referees and you have to adapt,'' said Smith.

"This weekend, for the team that adapts to the referee a lot quicker, it will be an advantage for them.'' Smith will be focused on that exact task this Saturday when the Wallabies take on Wales in their biggest pool round at Millennium Stadium in Cardiff.

"It's an important game and a game that we definitely would love to win, and win convincingly,'' said Smith who was not in the side that drew 29-29 to Wales at Cardiff last November, but did play when they went down 24-22 there in 2005.

"'It's always been a difficult task playing the Welsh at Millennium Stadium. It will be no different this weekend. We will definitely have to bring our 'A game'.'' Smith, whose spot in the Wallabies starting side is under constant threat from Phil Waugh who captained it at Cardiff last year, is enjoying his best ever form.

His try against Japan when he tackled and ripped the ball from Japanese No 13 Koji Taira and bolted 35m to score was simply superb.

"I blindsided him, came up with the ball, fended him off and went to the tryline.

''That 30-40m felt like 100m, said Smith. ''I don't have too many tries in a Wallaby jersey. But it would have been one of my best. I had my auntie and my cousins up in the stand who I heard went crazy.''

On form, it is hard to imagine Smith being benched against Wales to allow Waugh's return to the XV after being missing the 22-man squad for Japan.

But wherever he is named in the 22-man lineup on Wednesday, Smith realises that with 80 caps already at the age of 27 he is fast approaching a 100th test.

"I would like to make that century. But you have to play consistently good. I feel I am in the greatest form. And I have never felt as strong as I am, '' he said.

All Blacks look for a silver lining

By TONY SMITH in Marseille - Fairfax Media | Wednesday, 12 September 2007

The All Blacks will wear silver jerseys for the first time in their history in next week's World Cup clash with Scotland

Silver – or dark slate with black panels – has been the All Blacks' alternate strip for the last two years. But they have yet to wear it in a test match.

Previously the All Blacks played in white when forced to change due to a colour clash.

The general rule in rugby is home teams change strips – a reversal of the order that exists in international football where visitors turn up in their second-best clobber. Thus, the All Blacks have played in white against Scotland in New Zealand and the Scots have switched to white when hosting the All Blacks at Murrayfield.

Scotland plays the All Blacks in Edinburgh on September 23. But it is a World Cup fixture, and as such, is treated as a neutral match.

A toss was held some time ago to determine which side would wear its traditional strip. Scotland won the coinflip and will play in blue. The All Blacks will sport silver for the first time.

The colour clash issue – once a black and white matter – now has shades of grey for the All Blacks.

Several teams have now moved to darker strips. Wales has also adopted grey as its alternate uniform – an appropriate choice given its unconvincing performance against Canada.

Host nation France is wearing a much darker shade of navy blue at this tournament.

That could have proved to be a potential pitfall for the All Blacks if the two teams were to meet in the World Cup final.

But given France's wretched form against Argentina that may not be so much of a problem.

There is no colour clash between the green of South Africa and the black of New Zealand.

Meanewhile, Graham Henry may have promised his All Blacks "don't want to kill" Portugal, but that hasn;t stopped him sending for his heavy brigade – all 717kg of it.

Henry has stacked his squad with seven front-row forwards – almost certainly an All Black first – for Saturday's World Cup Pool C match in Lyons.

All three hookers and all four props have been named in the 22, although some have dual duties. First-choice hooker Keven Mealamu will start on the bench as loose forward cover. The world's top tighthead prop Carl Hayman will deputise at lock – his schoolboy position.

The poor Portugese will be quaking at their knees at the prospect of facing prime Kiwi beef, from Neemia Tialata, who tips the scales at 127kg, to Mealamu at a mere 106kg.

Henry continued his caring, sharing former school headmaster stance by insisting the All Blacks would show some sensitivity towards part-time Portugal.

Henry said the All Blacks would take a responsible approach at scrum-time. "If we've got dominance at scrum-time, and hopefully we will have, we just don't want to kill people, if you understand my logic.

"I think we need to be sensitive about, if we've got big scrum dominance, how we handle that scrum dominance and make sure we look after opposition props to some extent. I think that's pretty important."

Henry explained his rationale for choosing five forwards and two backs on his bench by stating that the concrete-mixers in the tight five need as much time on the track as they can get.

Anton Oliver, who will again be the reserve rake, agreed with the big-is-best stance, although he used slightly bigger words than his gaffer.

"With our physiology, we probably need to play more because we are bigger chaps and aerobic fitness is harder to come by," Oliver said. "The steaks are more alluring, especially in the south of France."'

While Hayman, Mealamu, Tony Woodcock , Tialata and Oliver all saw action against Italy, this will be the first outing for starting hooker Andrew Hore and tighthead prop Greg Somerville, who will play his first test of the year.

With locks Keith Robinson and Reuben Thorne on the mend from chronic leg injuries, skipper Richie McCaw is the only fully fit forward not named for the Portugal mismatch. Henry has confirmed he will revert to naming close to his top team for the third pool match against Scotland.

Collins will lead the All Blacks for the second time after his captaincy bow in Buenos Aires last year against Argentina.

Sione Lauaki will start his first test since 2005 at No 8 with Chris Masoe replacing McCaw on the openside flank.

The speedy Brendon Leonard and Nick Evans have been paired in the inside backs with Conrad Smith recovered from a hamstring strain to play at centre, outside Aaron Mauger.

The most interesting backline selection is the naming of specialist centre Isaia Toeava on the right wing –_ opposite Josevata Rokocoko.

Henry said Smith and Toeava would both get game time at centre and the selectors believed "Isaia's probably our fourth winger".

Backs coach Wayne Smith said the public should not read too much into Toeava's placement on the wing. "I think he's good enough to play a lot of positions. But he's also good enough to nail down one position. This is just a case of us needing to give Conrad time as well. It's to meet our needs more than anything else."

Burger suspended for four matches

12/09/2007 allblacks.com

Following a RWC 2007 judicial hearing Schalk Burger has been banned for four matches for "executed a reckless and sloppy tackle that was high and dangerous whilst the opposing player was in the air and therefore in a vulnerable position".

It was determined that the offence was in the mid range of seriousness. "There were no aggravating circumstances. However, there were several mitigating factors including Burger's remorse in relation to the incident, his excellent conduct during the hearing and his good disciplinary record. During 34 Tests for South Africa, 42 Rebel Sport Super 14 games and 22 Currie Cup games for his province he had never been before a disciplinary committee for such an offence.

The entry point for a mid range offence is six matches. However the it was decided in this case the suspension should be four matches in light of the mitigating factors.

Tuesday, 11 September 2007

These ABs would have 'belted us' - Foxy

Monday, 10 September 2007

Ever the realist, Grant Fox does not view the past with misty-eyed romanticism.

Fox was the points-scoring machine in the New Zealand All Blacks side who won their only World Cup to date in 1987.

A pragmatic flyhalf with no frills, Fox kicked 17 of New Zealand's 29 points in the final against France and totalled 645 in his international career.

The 1987 team led by David Kirk were a fine side. Over the next two years under Wayne Shelford they touched greatness. How, Fox was asked, would they have fared against modern day professional teams?

"They'd belt us," Fox said without hesitation in an interview in London as the All Blacks prepared in Marseille for their latest tilt at the elusive William Webb Ellis trophy.

"I saw some video clips recently in New Zealand of us playing in the World Cup final and we were small and we were skinny and we had those awful shorts that were so high, it was embarrassing to watch.

"In our era we were a pretty useful side. But if we took us as athletes then and the way the game was played then, and put us up against these guys they would kill us. They're bigger, stronger, faster, fitter."

Comparisons over the decades with the vast changes in diet, equipment and training are meaningless in most sports and particularly so in rugby union which was still an amateur game in Fox's day.

Fox instanced Bert Cooke ("nine stone wringing wet"), the electric centre in the 1924 side, and Colin Meads, voted by the New Zealand public as the greatest All Black of them all, as players who would be outstanding in any era.

"Colin Meads would be a great player today. But he would play six, he wouldn't be tall enough for a lock now although in his day he was huge," Fox said.

"If you took a lot of the players from that 87, 88 and 89 side and put them in a modern day environment they would be great players today."

The Berlin Wall was still standing when New Zealand last won the World Cup and Ronald Reagan was president of the United States. Did Fox think on June 20, 1987, that his nation would still be waiting for a second trophy 20 years later?

"If I was brutally honest, no," he replied. "In New Zealand the public are desperate for it, of course. In a funny way they're almost more desperate than the players.

"There will be a lot of relieved people in New Zealand if we succeed this time around. If not? It will just be four more years." – Reuters


Honiss under siege as 'worst' ref

By TONY SMITH in Marseille - Fairfax Media | Tuesday, 11 September 2007

New Zealand referee Paul Honiss has taken a hammering from the international press and Samoan officials for some key calls in Samoa's loss to South Africa. His performance was rated the "worst in World Cup history".

Samoan coach Michael Jones said he did not want to make the refereeing an excuse for the 59-7 defeat on Sunday. But he called on referees to be consistent and even-handed.

"We're not dumb. We know how to play this game. I'd like to think they (the referees) are looking at the teams through the same lenses. Everyone's accountable because there's so much at stake here. All we ask for is consistency."

Jones, the former All Black superstar, said referees were "paid enough and trained enough to get it right 95 per cent of the time".

"When it comes to the World Cup they have to get it right, especially for little nations like us."

Samoan captain Semo Sititi was even more scathing after the match, saying he was very disappointed with Honiss' rulings and that he had told him "there are two teams out here playing, not one".

"Always these decisions go against us, and they have an effect."

However, Springboks skipper John Smit had no qualms with Honiss.

"That was one of his best games," the Sharks hooker said.

Honiss was under fire in the international media for refusing to award Samoa a second-half try to Joe Tekori, ruling he was off-side at a ruck.

There was also an outcry when he failed to sin-bin Springbok flanker Schalk Burger for taking Samoa's Junior Polu out in mid-air.

New Zealand video referee Bryce Lawrence was also criticised for awarding a dubious try to Bryan Habana – one of four the Springbok wing scored.

Some international journalists also believed play should have been over before Percy Montgomery scored to give South Africa a 21-7 lead at half-time.

Leading English rugby writer Chris Hewett implied Honiss' refereeing display was the worst in World Cup history.

The New Zealander's performance "plumbed depths previously unvisited by officials at a World Cup, including his good self. And he has a fair bit of history in this regad, does Honiss," Hewett wrote in London's Independent.

Both Hewett and Guardian writer Paul Rees said the Argentinians had only just stopped complaining about Honiss' rulings on their scrummaging in the 2003 World Cup opener against Australia.

"It is hard enough for the developing nations, hampered as they are by a lack of finance and an inadequate competitive playing programme, to keep pace with the leading teams without referees such as the New Zealander Paul Honiss to further widen the divide with uneven decision-making," Rees wrote

A chance to reflect on early form

By Neil Reid, Yahoo!Xtra Sports
September 11, 2007

The most notable thing about day four of the Rugby World Cup is that there are no games on today

To date four teams - Georgia, Tonga, Fiji and Romania - are yet to touch the ball in anger at the tournament.

They will get their first taste of the atmosphere in France on Tuesday and Wednesday (local time).

So after each of the big-guns has had a crack, it's a good time to review their early form. Here is how I see it to date.

The All Blacks: Unleashed an amazing opening 25-minute burst against Italy, eventually destroying them 76-14.
It was a great statement of intent, especially considering the side hasn't played a test since July.

The Springboks: Inspired by a four-try burst from Brian Habana, the physicality they showed in the 59-7 win over Manu Samoa should have rivals taking notice.

The Wallabies: The 91-3 win over Japan looked great on the scoreboard, but it has exposed the side to some nasty early injury concerns. Mark Gerrard's World Cup lasted just 30 seconds before suffering a tournament-ending knee injury. But it was a strong allround showing from the Wallabies.

France: The mountain of expectation as hosts got the better of them against Argentina. It highlighted the inconsistency of France. That too is a threat, they are just as likely to turn on champagne rugby at the flick of a switch.

England and Ireland: Fans of the respective teams would hate to be lumped together. But unfortunately, the chances of their respective nations winning the World Cup are the same - NIL.

What do you guys think?

Honiss under the pump yet again!

The ref so many New Zealand fans love to hate has already made headlines for the wrong reasons in France.

His handling of Saturday's Springbok/Manu Samoa clash has been rubbished in some sections of the media.

The efforts of his New Zealand touch-judge Lyndon Bray and TMO Bryce Lawrence have also come in for a public slaying.

And it isn't just the media who have taken pot-shots at Mr Honiss.

The normally-reserved Manu Samoa captain Semo Sititi had no hesitation in venting his spleen at a post-match media conference.

Sititi stated: "I was very disappointed with the referee.
"I hope I don't get fined for saying this. I told him: There are two teams playing here, not one.

"The decisions always seemed to go against us and our spirit went down."

I too hope Sititi isn't fined. If anyone should be hit in the pocket after the match, it should be Honiss.

I didn't make the game - but I made the after-match!

It was with great sadness that I had to turn down an offer to play in a rugby festival on the outskirts of Marseille on Sunday.

Securing follow-ups to the breaking news of Steve Hansen's departure from the All Black camp, and the need to check on the side's injury status, meant missing the media session would not have been a wise thing.

But I did have the pleasure of getting to the official after-match function for the tournament that includes sides from France, Slovenia and Italy.

And what a night - another pearler of an evening here in Marseille.

Taking on a street party feeling, it was hosted on the same small lane that is home to the Little Canterbury bar.

As the amber liquid flowed throughout the night, each team took turns at performing its own adopted anthem.

There was even an Italian haka. Seriously!

I returned to my hotel late in the evening armed with some lovely gifts given to me to take back to New Zealand.

The hospitality of the Marseille people is a common theme of this blog - and it will certainly be one of the biggest things I will cherish from my own World Cup journey!

Boks` Burger cited

Tuesday 11th September 2007

Springbok flank Schalk Burger has been cited for a dangerous tackle on Samoan scrum-half Junior Polu during his team's 59-7 World Cup win on Sunday.

The burly Bok forward now faces the prospect of missing out on his team's crunch Pool A match against England at Stade de France, Saint Denis, on Friday.

Burger was not sin-binned by referee Paul Honiss, after taking out Polu in mid-air, a decision which caused fury in the Samoan camp.

But the incident has been picked up by citing commissioner Douglas Hunter and Burger will appear in front of a disciplinary hearing as soon as it can be arranged.

Burger is a key player for the Springboks and a guilty verdict could see him suspended from Friday's pivotal game in Paris.

England are also sweating over a disciplinary ruling ahead of the game, with captain Phil Vickery due to appear in front of a hearing on Tuesday.

Vickery was cited for kicking United States centre Paul Emerick during England's 28-10 victory at the weekend.

www.planetrugby.com